Man of Steel (2013), like the 1978 version, is also an origin story. The difference here is Jonathan Kent and his paranoia/caution. He tamps down Clark’s impulse to help and intervene, to show what he can do, so the government won’t come and take him away. It makes for a darker version than Richard Donner’s upbeat take. The world here is more suspicious, less trusting.
Because Cavill in real life is a dedicated gamer, I will always think well of him. Also, to be utterly superficial, Clark takes off his shirt now and then. I give this portrayal a thumb’s up.
His Superman is a good man with strong instincts, but Jonathan’s influence has made him more of a philosopher. He hesitates before jumping into action. I guess that indicates he, like Reeve’s portrayal, is a Nine concerned with justice. However, I don’t think this Clark would turn back the Earth’s rotation to save Lois. It was an impulsive act, something Jonathan’s son doesn’t do.
And he doesn’t get a Lex Luthor as his nemesis. The villain is General Zod, escaped from Krypton’s destruction. By choosing a space alien, this version is less charming or fantastical, fitting more into the science fiction genre.
No wigs, sadly.
I’m not a fan of Zod and his plotline. Hackman’s Luthor had a ridiculous goal: hit the San Andreas fault with nukes and cause California to drop into the sea, creating new property (owned by Lex) on the Pacific Ocean. Preposterous, but also easy to understand. Zod’s goal — kill humanity so that Krypton survivors could populate the Earth? — is much more complicated. Superman is stronger than them because he grew up here and absorbed the sun’s radiation. Again, so complicated. This density diminishes the Superman portrayal. Honestly, I don’t want to think this much for a comic book story. Keep it simple, please.
Clark’s internal struggle, a result of Jonathan’s parenting, is enough of a fresh twist. What if Superman doesn’t immediately help the human race? The government doesn’t trust him and possibly wants to harm him as a way of controlling him. It makes sense for him to hesitate. And yet, Clark is compelled by his own ethos to do good. Either way, we have a Nine, and successfully so. I just wish Zod hadn’t been the center of the conflict.
